The First Review: The 2008 Subaru Legacy Sedan

My Quick Impressions:

I recently drove the 2008 Subaru Legacy Sedan. Besides having goodies like power windows and door locks, it had a tilt and telescopic steering wheel, cruise control, moonroof, outside temperature gauge, and an AM/FM CD stereo with XM satellite radio. The powertrain was a 2.5-liter horizontally-opposed (or flat) four-cylinder with 175 hp and 169 foot pounds of torque, with a 4-speed automatic transmission (with manual shift mode). Safety-wise, it came with a full assortment of front and side airbags, as well as anti-lock brakes.

Acceleration from the 2.5 liter, horizontally-opposed 4 cylinder engine seemed merely adequate; even when I utilized the manual shift mode, it just seemed a bit underpowered--and I was craving for more. Perhaps an additional 10 to 15 more horses, or even something as simple as a fifth gear for the transmission would have provided swifter acceleration and better passing power. I found the driving experience in the Subaru to be decent during my 400-plus mile trip; the seats were generally comfortable with good support.

Passenger and trunk space were good, and the interior pieces seemed to be made of nice materials--they did not look cheap at all. The ergonomics of the interior were also very good. While the cabin was quiet for the most part, it could have used more sound insulation. The ride and handling was okay, but it was far too easy to feel bumps in the road--it seemed to "bottom out." The suspension could have been a bit softer sprung for more ride comfort. In short, I found that my driving experience in the Legacy was quite unremarkable--not sporty as I had hoped.

The styling of the Subaru Legacy is nice at all angles--except for the rear end of the car. The rear bumper styling is unattractive, ruining what could have been an overall terrific exterior design. Fuel economy was decent; in mixed driving, the Legacy's average MPG was in the low to mid-20's. Finally, I found myself wanting to like the Legacy a lot; nevertheless, its shortcomings left me wanting much more from it. However, the Legacy has good resale value and and a decent reputation for reliability, so shoppers should, at the very least, give it some consideration as a satisfactory new or used car choice.

The Car Exam Grade: B-

Written by P.S. (11/5/08)

Photos by P.S.

If you have any comments, feel free to respond. :)